Benchmarking: what it is, types, examples and how to do it step by step
How to compare yourself with whoever does it best, understand why and decide what to change in your business
Benchmarking is a management technique that compares your processes or results with those of whoever does it best, so you can learn from them and improve.
It’s not about copying. It’s about finding a point of reference, measuring the gap between you and it, and deciding what to change to close it.
The reference can be a competitor, a company in a different industry or even another department in your own company.
What does benchmarking mean?
The word comes from benchmark, which means “point of reference”. It is also known as comparative evaluation or comparative analysis.
In everyday use you’ll also see benchmark on its own for the reference figure: “your industry’s open rate benchmark”, for example.
Origin: the Xerox case
Benchmarking as a business method is associated with Xerox. In the late 1970s, the company found that its Japanese competitors were selling photocopiers for about what it cost Xerox to make them.
Instead of simply cutting prices, it studied in depth how those competitors worked and redesigned its own processes.
Then it went further: to improve its logistics, it looked at L.L. Bean, a catalog retailer that fulfilled orders much faster. It wasn’t a competitor, but it was the best at what Xerox needed.
Robert C. Camp, who led those studies, described it in his book Benchmarking (1989), which made the technique a standard.
Types of benchmarking
There are four main types. They differ in who you compare yourself with:
| Type | Who you compare yourself with | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Internal | Other teams, stores or offices in your company | The best-selling store teaches its method to the others |
| Competitive | Your direct competitors | Comparing prices, delivery times or customer service |
| Functional | Companies in another industry that are very good at a specific function | Xerox and L.L. Bean’s logistics |
| Generic | Any organization with an exemplary process | Adapting a hotel’s booking system to a clinic |
Competitive benchmarking is the best known, but functional benchmarking usually produces the most original ideas. Your competitors have the same limitations as you. Another industry doesn’t.

How do you do benchmarking step by step?
Useful benchmarking doesn’t require a consultancy. These are the steps:
- Choose what you want to improve. A specific process or result, not “all of marketing”.
- Decide what you’ll measure. Pick two or three KPIs, such as delivery time or conversion rate.
- Find your benchmark. A competitor, a company in another industry or your best internal team.
- Collect the data. Websites, public reports, customer reviews, industry studies or, internally, your own figures.
- Analyze the gap. Where are you and where is the benchmark? Why?
- Make a plan and measure. Define what you’ll change, with SMART goals, and repeat the comparison a few months later.
Step 5 is the one most often skipped. Knowing that someone else does it better is useless if you don’t understand why.
Advantages and limits of benchmarking
Done well, benchmarking gives you real reference points instead of assumptions. It helps you prioritize: if your delivery time is twice the average, you know where to start.
It also has limits:
- Other companies’ data is incomplete. You see what a company shows, not how it achieves it or what it costs.
- Copying doesn’t set you apart. If you only imitate the leader, at best you’ll get to where it was.
- Industry figures are misleading. An average mixes companies that are different from yours.
That’s why it’s worth combining it with other tools, such as SWOT analysis or Porter’s 5 forces.
Benchmarking in email marketing
Benchmarking is common in email marketing: you compare your campaigns’ metrics with a benchmark to know whether they are doing well or badly.
You have two possible benchmarks:
| Benchmark | What it tells you | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Industry figures | Whether you’re above or below the norm | Each study measures differently; use them only as a guide |
| Your own campaigns | Whether you’re improving or getting worse over time | Compare similar sends: same list, same type of email |
The second is usually more useful. Your list, your industry and your writing style are unique, and the most reliable comparison is with yourself.
A simple way to start is to note down the figures for each send in a spreadsheet: opens, clicks, unsubscribes and complaints. After three months you’ll have your own benchmark. And if you want to compare two versions of the same email, an A/B test gives you the answer with your own subscribers.
If you’re looking for benchmark figures, our roundup of email marketing statistics has data from neutral sources.

Your best benchmark is your own campaigns
With Mailrelay’s free account you get statistics for every send to compare and improve, and you can send up to 80,000 emails a month to 20,000 contacts.
Frequently asked questions about benchmarking
These are the most common questions when you start comparing.
What’s the difference between benchmarking and competitor analysis?
Competitor analysis describes what your competitors do. Benchmarking goes a step further: it compares a specific figure or process with yours and looks for ways to close the gap. Also, it doesn’t have to be limited to competitors.
How often should you do benchmarking?
It depends on how quickly what you measure changes. For email metrics, a quarterly review is usually enough. For processes such as logistics or customer service, once a year or whenever something important changes.