Clickbait: what it is, examples and how to avoid it in your emails

Seven types of misleading headlines, how to spot them and how to write subject lines that get opened without fooling anyone

“You won’t believe what happened next.” You’ve surely seen headlines like this and, almost without meaning to, clicked. Then comes the disappointment: there was nothing surprising about the content. That’s clickbait, and it works precisely because it plays on your curiosity.

What is clickbait?

Clickbait is a headline, subject line or thumbnail designed to get the click by exaggerating or hiding what’s behind it. In Spanish it’s called “ciberanzuelo”, the alternative recommended by Fundéu, or “cebo de clics”.

The key isn’t that the headline is eye-catching. It’s that the content doesn’t deliver what it promises. A good headline sparks interest and then satisfies it. Clickbait only takes care of the first part, and the reader is left feeling they’ve been fooled.

It works because of what psychologists call the curiosity gap: if you’re told half of something, your brain wants to know the other half. The same happens with subliminal advertising: when the audience discovers the trick, the brand loses their trust.

The origin of clickbait

The term emerged with the growth of digital media and social networks. Many publishers discovered that exaggerated headlines multiplied their traffic. Since their revenue depended on advertising, every click was worth money.

Around 2013, the curiosity headline we all recognize today became fashionable (“What happened next will surprise you”). But users learned to spot it and the platforms reacted. In 2016 Facebook changed its algorithm to show fewer headlines that withhold information or exaggerate, and Google and YouTube also reduce the visibility of misleading content.

Common examples of clickbait

Some patterns are repeated so often that they’re easy to identify. In this table you’ll find the most common ones, why they’re clickbait and what an honest version would look like:

TypeClickbait exampleHonest version
Forced mystery“What this customer discovered will leave you speechless”“How this customer cut unsubscribes by 30% in three months”
Exaggerated promise“This trick will double your sales in 24 hours”“Three changes to your cart email that recover sales”
List with a surprise“10 marketing mistakes, number 7 will surprise you”“10 marketing mistakes we see in small businesses”
Mysterious enemy“Banks hate this savings method”“How to save €50 a month with one simple rule”
False urgency“Last chance” in an email that arrives every week“The January offer ends Sunday at 11:59 p.m.”
Fake conversation“RE: your order” in an email you never sent“What’s new in our store for your next order”
Misleading thumbnailVideo with an astonished face and a red arrow pointing at something that never appearsThumbnail showing the actual result the video shows

They’re all after the same thing. Getting you to click before you think.

Seven types of clickbait with an example of each: forced mystery, exaggerated promise, list with a surprise, mysterious enemy, false urgency, fake conversation and misleading thumbnail

Subject lines that get opened without fooling anyone

Create your free account on Mailrelay and try out your subject lines with A/B tests before sending to your whole list.

How to spot clickbait

Before you click, look out for these signs:

  • It hides the key information (“this trick”, “this thing”, “what happened”).
  • It promises huge results in very little time.
  • It appeals to emotion, not information (“will leave you speechless”, “you won’t believe it”).
  • It uses capital letters, exclamation marks or alarm emojis.
  • The link or the sender has nothing to do with what the headline announces.

Clickbait in email marketing: why it costs you

On a blog, a deceptive headline costs you a disappointed visit. In email marketing, the damage is greater, because the reader has a button to punish you: marking your message as spam.

A misleading email subject line can raise the open rate of a particular campaign. What comes next is usually worse: more unsubscribes, more complaints and fewer clicks inside the email.

Mailbox providers keep an eye on those signals. If many recipients ignore or report your emails, your sender reputation drops. And with it, your deliverability: your next campaigns will land in the spam folder more often.

On top of that, some typical clickbait formulas, such as capital letters, excessive exclamation marks or impossible promises, trigger antispam filters.

Infographic comparing a clickbait email subject line with an honest subject line and their effects in the inbox

How to write compelling subject lines without resorting to clickbait

Curiosity isn’t the enemy. The trick is to spark interest and then deliver on what you announce. These guidelines will help:

  1. Be specific. “5 welcome templates you can copy today” builds more trust than “The secret nobody tells you”.
  2. Only promise what the email delivers. If the subject line mentions a discount, the discount has to be in the first line.
  3. Rely on the preheader. The preheader completes the subject line and removes the feeling of empty mystery.
  4. Use wit, not deception. A well-placed play on words grabs attention without hiding anything.
  5. Test before you decide. An A/B test tells you which subject line works best with your list, without any need to exaggerate.

Although it may seem contradictory, honest subject lines tend to deliver better results in the medium term. Readers learn that your emails are worth it and open them out of habit.

How Mailrelay helps you

At Mailrelay, we know that a good subject line is a mix of copywriting and data. That’s why you can run A/B tests on your subject line, so you decide based on figures rather than hunches.

On the free account and the Enterprise plan, the reports for each send show you opens, clicks and unsubscribes. That way, you can spot right away if a subject line attracts opens but disappoints inside the email. The editor also includes AI-assisted writing, which suggests clearer subject line alternatives.

And since Mailrelay always works with double opt-in, your list is made up of people who asked for your emails. You don’t need tricks to get your emails opened: all you need is to tell your readers something that interests them.

Write clear subject lines and measure what works

Up to 80,000 emails a month for free, with an AI editor and human support on every plan.

Frequently asked questions about clickbait

Is clickbait illegal? Generally, no. But if the headline is misleading about a product or a price, it may be considered misleading advertising and break consumer protection and unfair competition laws.

What’s the difference between clickbait and a persuasive headline? A persuasive headline delivers on its promise. Clickbait creates an expectation that the content doesn’t meet.

Key takeaways about clickbait

Clickbait can give you a spike in clicks or opens, but that boost is short-lived. In exchange, you put at risk something much harder to win back: your audience’s trust.

In email marketing, that trust translates into deliverability, so it’s worth looking after. A clear, specific and honest subject line almost always wins in the long run.

Related posts