Consumer psychology: what it is, what drives a purchase and how to apply it to your marketing

Why you choose one brand over another: the motivations behind every purchase and how to speak to them in your emails

Jose Argudo , CMO @ Mailrelay

Consumer psychology studies why we buy what we buy: the needs, emotions, beliefs and mental shortcuts behind every purchase decision.

Understanding it helps you talk about what really matters to your customers, not just about what you sell.

Here are the most common consumer motivations and the psychological factors that influence buying.

And how to apply them in your emails without crossing the line into manipulation.

Quick definition of consumer psychology

Consumer psychology is the branch of psychology that analyzes how people think, feel and decide when they buy or use a product.

It sits between psychology and marketing. It takes what we know about the human mind and applies it to purchase decisions.

What is consumer psychology for?

It helps you answer very practical questions:

  • Why a customer chooses your product over a competitor’s.
  • What holds them back right before they buy.
  • Which message will get them to open your email or click the button.
  • Why they buy again, or why they don’t come back.

It isn’t about guessing. It’s about forming hypotheses about your customers and testing them with data.

Consumer psychology and consumer behavior

They are similar, but they are not the same thing. Consumer psychology looks at what goes on inside people’s heads: motivations, perception, emotions.

Consumer behavior looks at what people do: where they search, how they buy, how much they spend. One explains the other.

📌 Motivation and emotion

Motivation is the force that drives a person to act to meet a need or fulfill a desire.

Without motivation, there’s no purchase. That’s why it’s the part of consumer psychology that’s most worth understanding.

What are consumer motivations?

Consumer motivations are the reasons, conscious or not, that lead someone to look for, choose and buy a product.

There’s hardly ever just one. Someone buying running shoes wants comfort, but also wants to feel athletic or fit in with their group of friends.

Types of buying motivations

Motivations are usually grouped into types. The table shows each one, what the customer is looking for and an example.

TypeWhat the customer is looking forExample
RationalPrice, quality, time savings, usefulnessChoosing the phone plan with the most data for the same price
EmotionalPleasure, security, peace of mind, feeling goodTreating yourself after a tough week
SocialBelonging, status, approval from othersBuying the brand the people around you use
Self-actualizationGrowing, learning, becoming betterSigning up for a language course
AvoidanceNot losing out, not making a mistake, not being left outBuying travel insurance before a trip
Infographic showing the 5 types of buying motivations: rational, emotional, social, self-actualization and avoidance

Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation

Intrinsic motivation comes from your own interest: you buy a book because you feel like reading it.

Extrinsic motivation depends on something external: a discount, a gift, loyalty points or what others will think.

Deci and Ryan’s self-determination theory, from 1985, explains why intrinsic motivation tends to last longer.

In marketing, both work. The coupon brings in the first purchase. Genuine interest in the product is what brings the second.

Consumer needs and motivations

Every motivation starts with a need. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs sorts them into five levels: physiological, safety, belonging, esteem and self-actualization.

Marketing doesn’t invent those needs. It turns them into specific wants, as we explain in the difference between needs and wants.

Being thirsty is a need. Wanting a soft drink from a specific brand is a want.

The role of emotions in buying

Emotions aren’t the opposite of reason. They’re the shortcut we use to decide quickly when there are too many options.

That’s why emotional marketing works: a story or an image is remembered better than a list of features.

The emotions that drive purchases the most are excitement, peace of mind, pride and nostalgia.

And, on the other side, the fear of losing out.

Test what motivates your customers

Compare two subject lines or two offers with an A/B test and let the data decide.

📌 Fundamentals of consumer psychology

Consumer psychology draws on several schools of psychology. Each one explains a part of buying.

SchoolWhat it explainsMarketing example
BehaviorismWe learn through association and rewardPoints programs and loyalty cards
CognitivismWe process information before decidingComparison sites, reviews, detailed product pages
HumanismWe seek to grow and feel fulfilledMessages about self-improvement and purpose
Behavioral economicsWe decide using mental shortcuts and biasesPrice anchoring, limited-time offers

Consumer perception

Perception is how customers interpret what they see, hear or read about your brand.

Two people can see the same ad and take away different things. Their experiences, their expectations and what they already think of your brand all play a part.

On top of that, attention is selective: the brain filters out almost everything that doesn’t interest it at that moment.

In the inbox, that filter lasts a few seconds.

That’s why your brand image, your sender and your subject line carry so much weight: they’re the first things people notice.

📌 Learning and memory

Consumers learn from every experience with a brand. And what they remember decides whether they buy again.

How consumers learn

Consumer learning follows three main paths:

  • Through association. If a brand always appears alongside something pleasant, we end up associating it with that feeling.
  • Through reinforcement. If a purchase goes well, we repeat it. If it goes badly, we avoid it for a long time.
  • Through observation. We copy what we see others do, especially people we admire or trust.

For example: if your emails always bring something useful, your list learns they’re worth opening. If they only bring offers, it learns to ignore them.

Memory and brand recall

What isn’t remembered isn’t bought. Consumer memory holds only a few brands per category, and not always the best ones.

The mere-exposure effect, described by Robert Zajonc in 1968, explains why we tend to prefer what feels familiar.

That’s why consistency matters.

A newsletter that arrives every week, from the same sender and with a recognizable style, keeps your brand in the customer’s memory.

📌 Attitudes and persuasion in consumer psychology

An attitude is what a person thinks and feels about a brand, and how they tend to act toward it.

Components of attitudes

It’s usually explained with the ABC model:

  • Affective. What they feel: “I like this brand.”
  • Behavioral. What they do or plan to do: “I’ll buy it again.”
  • Cognitive. What they believe they know: “It’s the best value for money.”

Changing an attitude is slow. It’s easier to reinforce a positive attitude than to turn a negative one around.

Biases that influence buying

Cognitive biases are mental shortcuts that save us effort, but sometimes lead us to make not-so-rational decisions.

These six are the ones that come up most in purchases.

For more detail, read our article on cognitive biases and their impact on sales.

BiasWhat it isHow it looks in an email
Social proofWe trust what others choose“More than 2,000 readers already get this guide”
ScarcityWe value what might run out more“Only 12 spots left for the workshop”
Loss aversionLosing hurts more than gaining the same amount“Your discount expires on Sunday”
AnchoringThe first number shapes everything elseOld price crossed out next to the new one
ReciprocityWe want to give back what we receiveA free template before asking for the sale
Decoy effectA third option makes another one look more attractiveThree plans, with the middle one highlighted

Loss aversion comes from Kahneman and Tversky’s prospect theory (1979).

The decoy effect was popularized by Dan Ariely with an example of The Economist subscriptions.

Many of these biases overlap with Cialdini’s principles of persuasion and with FOMO.

Persuading without manipulating

Persuading is convincing with true arguments and letting the other person choose. Manipulating is using those same biases with false information.

Made-up scarcity, a countdown that resets or a fake “RE:” in the subject line work once.

After that, they lead to distrust, unsubscribes and spam complaints.

The rule is simple: use biases only when what you’re saying is true. We go deeper into this in marketing: satisfaction or manipulation?.

Subject lines that spark curiosity

Personalize with the contact’s name and test different approaches until you find the one that works best.

📌 Decision-making in consumer psychology

Most purchases follow a five-stage process. Sometimes it takes seconds, other times months.

StageWhat goes on in the customer’s headWhat you can do
1. Need recognitionThey notice something is missingContent that names the problem
2. Information searchThey research optionsGuides, comparisons, a useful newsletter
3. Evaluation of alternativesThey compare price, quality, trustReviews, real case studies, guarantees
4. Purchase decisionThey choose and buy, or give upA simple checkout, abandoned cart reminders
5. Post-purchase behaviorThey assess whether they made the right choiceWelcome email, support, survey
Infographic showing the 5 stages of the purchase decision: recognizing the need, searching for information, comparing alternatives, deciding and buying, and evaluating the purchase

At each stage, the customer needs a different message. That’s why a customer journey map and good segmentation make all the difference.

Rational and emotional factors

Daniel Kahneman explained it in Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011) with two systems of thinking.

System 1 is fast, intuitive and emotional. System 2 is slow, analytical and rational.

Small or impulse purchases are almost always decided by System 1.

Big ones, like a car or software for your business, go through System 2.

Even so, even in the most carefully considered purchases, emotion usually gives the final push.

Too many options also hold people back

The more options there are, the harder it is to decide. This is decision fatigue.

In an email, that means one idea per message and a single main button.

How to apply consumer psychology in your emails

Knowing the theory is fine, but where it shows is in what you write every week.

What I often see going wrong is that we don’t put ourselves in the consumer’s shoes. We create offers and promotions from our perspective as sellers, without putting ourselves in the shoes of the person who has to buy. That doesn’t usually work. We have to take customers’ real needs into account: understand what they need, what motivates them, what their real perspective is. And from there, make them an offer that’s genuinely useful to them. Without that, it’s very hard to sell.

Jose Argudo, CMO at Mailrelay

You can bring all of this into your newsletter with small changes:

  1. Talk about the motivation, not the product. Instead of “New Excel course,” try “Finish your reports in half the time.”
  2. Take care of what’s noticed first. A recognizable sender, a clear subject line and preview text that complements the subject.
  3. Use social proof with real data. Reviews, number of customers or named case studies.
  4. Give before you ask. A guide, a template or a useful tip triggers reciprocity.
  5. Use urgency only when it’s real. If the offer ends on Sunday, say so. If it doesn’t, don’t make it up.
  6. Segment by motivation. You don’t write the same way for someone looking for price as for someone looking for quality.
  7. Test your hypotheses. An A/B test tells you what really motivates your list, without guesswork.

How Mailrelay helps you

With Mailrelay, you can put all of this into practice from the free account. To start with, A/B tests let you compare two subject lines or two senders and keep the one that works best, and groups and segments let you send each contact the message that fits what they’re looking for.

With dynamic variables, you personalize the subject line and content with the name or other data, and with automations, you support customers at every stage: welcome, follow-up and post-purchase. Then, the statistics for each campaign tell you which messages work with your list.

Turn knowledge into sales

Create your free account and send up to 80,000 emails a month to 20,000 contacts.

Frequently asked questions about consumer psychology

These are the most common questions about consumer psychology.

What is consumer psychology in a nutshell?

It’s the study of why we buy: the needs, emotions, beliefs and mental shortcuts behind every purchase decision.

What are the main consumer motivations?

The most common are rational (price, usefulness), emotional (pleasure, peace of mind), social (belonging, status), self-actualization and avoidance, such as not losing out on something.

What psychological factors influence consumer behavior?

The four main ones are motivation, perception, learning and attitudes. Emotions and cognitive biases act on all of them.

Is it ethical to use consumer psychology in marketing?

Yes, if it’s used to understand customers better and communicate truthfully.

It stops being ethical when data, deadlines or scarcity are made up to force a purchase.

How can I find out what motivates my customers?

Ask them with surveys, check which content and offers get the most response, and run A/B tests with subject lines that appeal to different motivations.

Jose Argudo, CMO at Mailrelay

Jose Argudo

CMO at Mailrelay. Writes about email marketing, copywriting and conversion for small businesses and entrepreneurs.

More articles by Jose · LinkedIn