Graymail: what it is and how it differs from spam

The email someone signed up for and no longer reads: why Gmail treats it almost like spam and how to keep it from happening to your list

Two years ago you signed up for a store’s newsletter. Now it arrives every Tuesday, you see it in your inbox and you archive it without opening it. It isn’t spam, because you asked for it. But you don’t want it either. That’s graymail.

What is graymail?

Graymail is commercial email that the recipient agreed to receive at some point but is no longer interested in. Newsletters, promotions or brand announcements that the subscriber stopped reading and hasn’t yet bothered to unsubscribe from.

Microsoft popularized the term around 2011, when it added tools to Hotmail to clear this kind of email out of the inbox. The idea still holds: there is a space between the email someone expects and the email they never asked for, and part of what many companies send gets lost in it.

Graymail vs spam: how they differ

The difference is permission. Spam arrives without anyone asking for it. Graymail arrives with permission, but without interest.

SpamGraymail
Was there consent?NoYes, at the time
Is it legal to send?No, in the EUYes, as long as the permission is still valid
Who sends itUnknown or fraudulent sendersBrands the user knows
What the recipient doesDeletes or reports itIgnores it, archives it or marks it as spam because it’s easier
How it’s solvedWith antispam filtersWith segmentation, lower frequency and an easy unsubscribe

The problem is the last row of the table. When unsubscribing takes more effort than clicking “Report spam”, many people take the shortcut. And for Gmail or Outlook, that complaint counts the same as if the email were real spam.

Graymail vs spam: nobody asked for spam; graymail was requested at some point but is no longer wanted, so it gets ignored or marked as spam because it's easier

Send to the people who actually read you

Segment by activity and stop sending to inactive subscribers. Start with the free account.

Why does graymail happen?

It’s almost never in bad faith. It’s usually a combination of small causes:

  • Changing interests. Someone who subscribed to buy a sofa is no longer looking for sofas.
  • Too many sends. A high frequency turns a useful email into noise, which is known as list fatigue.
  • The same content for everyone. Without segmentation, each subscriber gets messages meant for someone else.
  • Hidden unsubscribe options. A tiny unsubscribe link or a multi-step process pushes people to ignore the email or report it.

How graymail affects your deliverability

Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo don’t just check whether an email is legitimate. They look at what people do with it. Opens, replies and messages moved to the primary inbox are good signals. Emails that nobody opens, that are deleted unread or that are marked as spam are bad ones.

A list full of graymail sends exactly those bad signals. Gmail’s sender guidelines require keeping the reported spam rate below 0.3% and recommend not going above 0.1%. A few complaints from bored subscribers are enough to bring you close to that limit.

The result is a lower sender reputation. And with it, more emails in the Promotions tab or in spam, including for the subscribers who did want to read you. That’s why graymail isn’t just an open-rate problem: it’s a deliverability problem.

How graymail affects deliverability: unopened emails, spam complaints, a worse sender reputation and more emails in spam

How to reduce graymail in your sends

  1. Get permission the right way from the start. Explain on the form what you’re going to send and how often. Double opt-in filters out people who sign up without real interest.
  2. Segment by activity. Separate the people who opened in the last few months from those who haven’t in half a year, and don’t send them the same thing.
  3. Adjust the frequency. If opens drop after you increase your sends, frequency is part of the problem.
  4. Make unsubscribing easy. A visible link and the List-Unsubscribe header let people unsubscribe in one click right from Gmail. An unsubscribe is much better than a complaint.
  5. Offer options. A preference center lets people who don’t want to leave entirely choose topics or frequency.
  6. Clean your list with a re-engagement campaign. Ask inactive subscribers whether they want to keep receiving your emails. Stop sending to anyone who doesn’t reply.

A smaller, active list reaches the inbox better than a large one where half the people don’t read you.

How Mailrelay helps

At Mailrelay every signup goes through double opt-in, so your list starts with contacts who have confirmed they want your emails. Every send includes an unsubscribe link and the List-Unsubscribe header, so leaving is easier than reporting you.

With segments you can separate the people who haven’t opened your latest campaigns and send them a re-engagement email, or stop sending to them. Open and click tracking is available on the free account and on the Enterprise plan.

The free account lets you send up to 80,000 emails a month to 20,000 contacts, and you get human support on every plan.

An active list reaches the inbox better

Double opt-in on every signup, one-click unsubscribe and human support on every plan.

Graymail FAQ

Is it illegal to send graymail? No. If the contact gave consent and hasn’t withdrawn it, you can keep sending to them. But just because it’s legal doesn’t mean it’s in your interest.

Is graymail the same as a greylist? No. Graymail is a type of email. A greylist (greylisting) is a server-side antispam technique that temporarily rejects the first delivery attempt from an unknown sender.

When should I remove an inactive subscriber? It depends on your sending frequency. With weekly sends, six months without opening or clicking is a clear signal. Before removing them, try a re-engagement email.

Key takeaways about graymail

Graymail is email that someone asked for and no longer wants. It isn’t spam, but mailbox providers treat it almost the same when nobody opens it or when it ends up marked as spam.

Segment, send less to people who don’t read and make unsubscribing easy. You’ll lose some contacts, but the ones who stay will read you.

Related posts